[Write On!]

Search Write On!

On the value of workshops

by mikepence
Posted to Diaries, Diary on Fri Oct 08, 2004 at 06:00:52 AM PST
[Print]
I was looking at some of the workshops available here in S. Florida and I have genuine concern about the true value of these kinds of events in moving ones writing forward.

These college workshops and this obsession with getting published in these small press literary dead tree rags seems dated to me. What do you think? Are workshops largely a waste of time?

I'm thinking that what I really need is a personal editor -- someone I could pay some money on a per piece basis to review my work and make substantive recommendations on how to tighten things up.

Waddya think?


Login
Make a new account
Username:
Password:
Related Links
Display: Sort:
On the value of workshops | 4 comments (4 topical, 0 hidden)
Depends on why you write, I think (3.00/0) (#1)
by janra on Fri Oct 08, 2004 at 09:22:09 AM PST
If you find "getting published in these small press literary dead tree rags" to be a worthwhile goal, then the workshops you mention are probably of value.

If you don't, they probably aren't.

Especially if, like me, you hear an excerpt from a story nominated for a big "literary" prize and think as it's being read by the author on national radio, "damn, that's awkward. Didn't he ever learn to leak details rather than dumping character description on the reader? Hm, the characters are lecturing each other. Why didn't he just write a damn essay?"

As for personal editors, if you have the money, great - there are a lot of editors out there that will happily take your cash and write on your story. How helpful that'll be... well, I think that would depend on the editor. I've found that critiquing other people's writing helped me learn to identify problems in my own writing; that plus a few books on self-editing has brought me to the level I'm at today. To improve, in my opinion, you need to know why you're making particular changes, not just what changes to make. If you can find an editor who'll explain the "why" and not just the "what" you've found a great resource.
--
Who needs to be big and burly when you can just apply physics?

Amazon (3.00/0) (#2)
by mikepence on Fri Oct 08, 2004 at 02:10:40 PM PST
Amazon keeps recommending Self Editing for Fiction Writers to me. Any feedback on that one? Which would you recommend?

Of course, I may be protesting a bit too much about "getting published in these small press literary dead tree rags." :-)

[ Parent ]

It's good. (3.00/0) (#3)
by janra on Fri Oct 08, 2004 at 03:06:35 PM PST
I have that one. Well, I think I have a different edition, because the cover is different. Same title and authors though.

I thought it was very good. It provided a balanced view of a lot of "rules" that people seem to follow to the extreme (the first chapter is about the "show, don't tell" rule), and showed examples with explanations of all kinds of things.

I think it was well worth the money :-)
--
Who needs to be big and burly when you can just apply physics?
[ Parent ]

Thank you (3.00/0) (#4)
by 5507 on Wed Oct 27, 2004 at 08:31:44 AM PST
 I am learning of new things all day! And it is good to know of my RSS already work. I think I need add button of RSS to make this thing clear.
 But more work to do!
down
On the value of workshops | 4 comments (4 topical, 0 hidden)
Display: Sort: